Law of Cards: Beckett Sues Two More for Scraping Data

The recent trend in trading card cases focuses more on protecting trading card data than on trading cards themselves. Beckett has filed two more lawsuits over alleged data scraping.

Collectors Universe (CU) started this trend with lawsuits against MWP Software/Matthew Perry and SaintSoft LLC/John Kountz. In both of these suits, CU alleged the defendants copied CU data available only to paying CU subscribers, and then unlawfully (and in violation of CU's terms of service) used that data on the defendants' websites or in their own apps.

Pokémon then followed by suing the Pokellector (a website which attempts to provide a comprehensive list of all Pokémon cards, along with images of those cards) for allegedly reproducing copyrighted images of its cards without permission, trademark infringement and unlawfully rebranding the images of Pokémon cards with a Pokellector trademark.

Beckett continued the trend by bringing a trade secret lawsuit against Check Out My Cards (COMC) which, among other things, made a big deal out of COMC's "scraping" of checklists and pricing data (although COMC alleges such scraping may have been authorized).

On April 24, Beckett filed two more lawsuits focusing on pricing and checklist data. This time against Custom Plush Productions Inc's The Card Collector and Derek Miller of Miller Cards.

These two new complaints cannibalize a lot of the COMC complaint and are nearly mirror images of each other as well.

It also looks like Beckett might have let an intern from the marketing department edit these complaints. Paragraph six of both state, "Beckett is the preeminent company and most trusted source operating within the collectibles industry, and it has been since it formed in 1984."

Sounds more like a PR piece than a lawsuit, right?

For The Card Collector case, Beckett alleges The Card Collector accessed Beckett's pricing guides through the Beckett website and unlawfully "scraped" Beckett's copyrightable checklist and pricing data. Allegedly, The Card Collector now offers Beckett's card checklists, grading and pricing data on its own website and through a CD-ROM it sells to others. For that Beckett brings claims for copyright infringement, common law misappropriation, "accounting" (bring out the accountants!), unjust enrichment, a violation of Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, trespass and a Harmful Access by Computer Under Texas Penal Code.

A little bit of everything, right?

For the second new suit, Beckett alleges Miller Cards operates several websites (such as millercards.net and freebaseballcardspriceguide.com) that provide checklists and pricing guides for card collectors. Beckett contends that Miller accessed Beckett's price guides through his Beckett membership, violated the membership agreement by "scraping" this data and then unlawfully reproduced the data on his websites. It brings the identical claims against Miller Cards that it brought against the Card Collector.

Giving all of this scraping going on, I guess, the next planking or Tebowing-type meme should be the "scraping" Beckett meme. I'm looking forward to seeing your pictures on what that should look like.

Now, we've only seen Beckett's side of the story, but it looks bad for both defendants. Sure, there are issues about how much copyright protection should be afforded checklists, but these cases are not just about publicly available checklist data. The checklist and pricing information from these cases was allegedly scraped from behind a pay wall at and then distributed to others in violation of Beckett's terms of service.

Allegedly stealing something from behind a pay wall to give or sell to others just doesn’t look good.

Given this, in all likelihood, these cases will disappear (settle) quickly before we get into any real issues.

These two cases (and the COMC case) have another implication for the industry. Beckett has a template complaint that it looks like it's going to recycle again and again against scrapers. And it's policing the Internet looking for infringers. I predict then we'll see this complaint filed again this year, perhaps multiple times.

If you'd like to review a copy of these complaints, click here for the Card Collector complaint and here for the Miller Cards complaint.

The information provided in Paul Lesko's "Law of Cards" column is not intended to be legal advice, but merely conveys general information related to legal issues commonly encountered in the sports industry. This information is not intended to create any legal relationship between Paul Lesko, the Simmons Browder Gianaris Angelides & Barnerd LLC or any attorney and the user. Neither the transmission nor receipt of these website materials will create an attorney-client relationship between the author and the readers.

The views expressed in the "Law of Cards" column are solely those of the author and are not affiliated with the Simmons Law Firm. You should not act or rely on any information in the "Law of Cards" column without seeking the advice of an attorney. The determination of whether you need legal services and your choice of a lawyer are very important matters that should not be based on websites or advertisements.

Source: http://www.cardboardconnection.com/news/law-of-cards-beckett-sues-two-more-for-scraping-data

Internet marking is the finest method of increment of popularity in commerce

In today’s world key to any business is right kind of marketing strategy that needs to be implemented for the success of any entrepreneurial project. One of the fastest growing ways is to get the listing of your company in top search engines. SEO is one of the ways which can help in increasing or diverting the traffic on any website. People should understand the search result of their website is displayed on the World Wide Web. Different search engines work in different ways by providing different ranking to websites according to the search of the people. This is why same website has different ranks on different search engines.

Basically, website owner provides the keywords to the SEO providers which are appropriate to their business. Business SEO providers make sure the owners are charged low and also providing correct information to search engines. Providing better SEO in Ottawa is the basic feature that service providers aim at, their main motive is to make these services available to all the common people so that they can benefit there business in a better way. A good SEO mostly uses popular sites like Google, Bing, Yahoo, Yellow pages etc.

These SEO companies make sure that the listing of their clients is upgraded by repeated updating and also there ranking reaches top on search engines. Consultations with SEO service provider can be availed for free by the website owners. SEO companies carefully chooses keyword for their clients because it has to be unique and commonly used to make them reach at the top .They do so by carefully analyzing the owners website and competitors website and then the strategy is made to determine the perfect keyword for their clients. Owner should make sure that the prices charged to him are competitive according to market.

Consultation and Analysis are important because the keyword formation is directly dependent on these two parameters if the SEO service provider fails to submit the proper keyword it would result in failure of whole SEO services for the owner. SEO provider can re create and also modify the keywords for any website. If anyone specifically looking to create a new SEO website for him then the Looking internet marketing company in ottawa specialists can help them in determining a new domain that could be related to the business of the owner. Secondly, good hosting service is provided by them which help a website fast to access by any user. The biggest task for Internet marketing specialist is Link building because it represents more than 80% result of SEO.

For any website owner good SEO link building can be good in this competitive world because it attracts the people. A good SEO developer plays a pivotal role in developing a perfect keyword for the company. Ottawa SEO companies are very famous to deliver their services to the customers at very reasonable prices. SEO services are available online one can visit their websites see the list of services offered by them, read the testimonials of the existing and choose from them pay online and get started.

For further detail about Business seo service in Ottawa please visit the website.

Source:http://blogs.siliconindia.com/businessseo/Business/Internet-marking-is-the-finest-method-of-increment-of-popularity-in-commerce-bid-cf9206bx84461691.html

Collecting Data With Web Scrapers

There is a large amount of data available only through websites. However, as many people have found out, trying to copy data into a usable database or spreadsheet directly out of a website can be a tiring process. Data entry from internet sources can quickly become cost prohibitive as the required hours add up. Clearly, an automated method for collating information from HTML-based sites can offer huge management cost savings.

Web scrapers are programs that are able to aggregate information from the internet. They are capable of navigating the web, assessing the contents of a site, and then pulling data points and placing them into a structured, working database or spreadsheet. Many companies and services will use programs to web scrape, such as comparing prices, performing online research, or tracking changes to online content.

Let's take a look at how web scrapers can aid data collection and management for a variety of purposes.

Improving On Manual Entry Methods

Using a computer's copy and paste function or simply typing text from a site is extremely inefficient and costly. Web scrapers are able to navigate through a series of websites, make decisions on what is important data, and then copy the info into a structured database, spreadsheet, or other program. Software packages include the ability to record macros by having a user perform a routine once and then have the computer remember and automate those actions. Every user can effectively act as their own programmer to expand the capabilities to process websites. These applications can also interface with databases in order to automatically manage information as it is pulled from a website.

Aggregating Information

There are a number of instances where material stored in websites can be manipulated and stored. For example, a clothing company that is looking to bring their line of apparel to retailers can go online for the contact information of retailers in their area and then present that information to sales personnel to generate leads. Many businesses can perform market research on prices and product availability by analyzing online catalogues.

Data Management

Managing figures and numbers is best done through spreadsheets and databases; however, information on a website formatted with HTML is not readily accessible for such purposes. While websites are excellent for displaying facts and figures, they fall short when they need to be analyzed, sorted, or otherwise manipulated. Ultimately, web scrapers are able to take the output that is intended for display to a person and change it to numbers that can be used by a computer. Furthermore, by automating this process with software applications and macros, entry costs are severely reduced.

This type of data management is also effective at merging different information sources. If a company were to purchase research or statistical information, it could be scraped in order to format the information into a database. This is also highly effective at taking a legacy system's contents and incorporating them into today's systems.

Overall, a web scraper is a cost effective user tool for data manipulation and management.

Source:http://ezinearticles.com/?Collecting-Data-With-Web-Scrapers&id=4223877

A range of Yellow pages scraper software to extract from the Internet

A range of software to extract from the Internet Yellow Pages

Montreal, Quebec - December 3, 2013 - Management-Ware Solutions Inc. is a Canadian based company working in the high technology field. Management-Ware Solutions is proud to launch its new product for extracting or scraping data from Yellow Pages - "Management-Ware Yellow Pages Scraper v1.0.0.4". This software can be used for collecting any type of information from different Yellow Pages domains like Yellowpages.com, Yellowpages.ca and yellowpages.com.au. Management-Ware Yellow Pages Scraper can be easily purchased and downloaded from

Our Yellow Pages Grabber is here! Use one of our Yellow Pages scrapers to build your own contact list.

Some marketers say that the fastest way to find the contact information for your target market is to buy mailing lists. Other marketers advice not to buy any list because these lists are not up-to-date.

Our Yellow Pages grabbers are designed to extract business information from the Yellow Pages directory with the latest and up-to-date information as per your customized requirement. We are offering yellow pages scraper for 3 different countries: United States, Canada and Australia.

Here are some key features of "Management-Ware Yellow Pages Scraper for USA, Canada and Australia":

    Grab online Yellow Pages business listings, phone numbers, addresses

    You can extract an unlimited number of records

    Search/ Extract by one or multiple keywords

    Search/ Extract by one or multiple URLs

    Search by keyword / by categories / by custom categories

    It supports Proxy (it hides your IP Address)

    Save data to CSV format. (CSV, Excel, html, PDF). Export to Excel

    It extracts relevant information from YP online directory

    It checks for duplicate entries in your database

    Activate the license in 2 computers

*Capture contact lists from Yellowpages.com, Yellowpages.ca and yellowpages.com.au

If you are looking for a quick and easy way to capture names, emails, addresses, phone numbers, fax numbers, and other contact details from Online directories like Yellowpages.com, then Management-Ware Yellow Pages Scraper for USA is the tool for you.

Source:http://www.management-ware.com/en/press-release/30-a-range-of-yellow-pages-scraper-software-to-extract-from-the-internet

Essay Assistance - Help With Essay Writing

Help with essay writing? Surely this must be frowned upon by the authorities. Academic writing should be the result of an individual's work, and a student should not ask for another writer to 'fix my essay'. That is certainly true of course, but there is a degree to which essay assistance is allowed, governed by a code of conduct set out by the universities.

There should be no plagiarism, of course, nor any 'ghosting', but online academic writing services exist for the important task of editing for 'clarity, flow and consistency.' The student can submit their essay for assessment in the vital areas of grammar, spelling and punctuation - and turnaround could be within 12 hours if necessary.

It can be very difficult to spot mistakes within one's own writing, academic or otherwise. This is one of the strengths of a professional proof-reading and editing service, which can correct grammar and spelling, sentence structure, and punctuation. This type of online service is always on hand, available 24-hours a day, all year round.

With essay assistance it is possible to submit your work for assessment, yet retain complete control of the finished assignment. The track changes function in Microsoft Word can be used to highlight any changes which have been made. These changes are suggestions only, which can be approved or amended when the document has been returned.

A lengthy essay such as a dissertation can certainly benefit from presentational essay assistance. Maintaining consistency throughout a dissertation is one of the challenges which can be difficult to optimise, and is easy to overlook. Such essay assistance may include the creation of pre-linked contents pages, management of heading and text formatting, inserting page breaks and cover pages, adding headers and footers, and creating dynamic referencing.

Grammatical style is another key element in the clear presentation of your work. Clarity of thought and the coherence of a well-plotted argument can be disguised by extended sub-clauses and the over-use of parentheses. If your reader is distracted from your main purpose then your most powerful points could be lost. This is an important aspect of essay assistance, and having your attention drawn to flaws in your grammatical style are far easier for a third party to identify. After all, you may know what you mean, but your reader must also be able to follow your line of thought.

There is no need to allow this to happen. If marks are lost due to failures in presentation or grammar, then a student will not only have undersold their true worth, but also wasted some of their energies. This is the significance of essay assistance, and with the ease of online access throughout the year it is a potential asset which should not be overlooked.

Source:http://ezinearticles.com/?Essay-Assistance---Help-With-Essay-Writing&id=6349475

Internet Data Mining - How Does it Help Businesses?

Internet has become an indispensable medium for people to conduct different types of businesses and transactions too. This has given rise to the employment of different internet data mining tools and strategies so that they could better their main purpose of existence on the internet platform and also increase their customer base manifold.

Internet data-mining encompasses various processes of collecting and summarizing different data from various websites or webpage contents or make use of different login procedures so that they could identify various patterns. With the help of internet data-mining it becomes extremely easy to spot a potential competitor, pep up the customer support service on the website and make it more customers oriented.

There are different types of internet data_mining techniques which include content, usage and structure mining. Content mining focuses more on the subject matter that is present on a website which includes the video, audio, images and text. Usage mining focuses on a process where the servers report the aspects accessed by users through the server access logs. This data helps in creating an effective and an efficient website structure. Structure mining focuses on the nature of connection of the websites. This is effective in finding out the similarities between various websites.

Also known as web data_mining, with the aid of the tools and the techniques, one can predict the potential growth in a selective market regarding a specific product. Data gathering has never been so easy and one could make use of a variety of tools to gather data and that too in simpler methods. With the help of the data mining tools, screen scraping, web harvesting and web crawling have become very easy and requisite data can be put readily into a usable style and format. Gathering data from anywhere in the web has become as simple as saying 1-2-3. Internet data-mining tools therefore are effective predictors of the future trends that the business might take.

Source: http://ezinearticles.com/?Internet-Data-Mining---How-Does-it-Help-Businesses?&id=3860679

Data Mining As a Process

The data mining process is also known as knowledge discovery. It can be defined as the process of analyzing data from different perspectives and then summarizing the data into useful information in order to improve the revenue and cut the costs. The process enables categorization of data and the summary of the relationships is identified. When viewed in technical terms, the process can be defined as finding correlations or patterns in large relational databases. In this article, we look at how data mining works its innovations, the needed technological infrastructures and the tools such as phone validation.

Data mining is a relatively new term used in the data collection field. The process is very old but has evolved over the time. Companies have been able to use computers to shift over the large amounts of data for many years. The process has been used widely by the marketing firms in conducting market research. Through analysis, it is possible to define the regularity of customers shopping. How the items are bought. It is also possible to collect information needed for the establishment of revenue increase platform. Nowadays, what aides the process is the affordable and easy disk storage, computer processing power and applications developed.

Data extraction is commonly used by the companies that are after maintaining a stronger customer focus no matter where they are engaged. Most companies are engaged in retail, marketing, finance or communication. Through this process, it is possible to determine the different relationships between the varying factors. The varying factors include staffing, product positioning, pricing, social demographics, and market competition.

A data-mining program can be used. It is important note that the data mining applications vary in types. Some of the types include machine learning, statistical, and neural networks. The program is interested in any of the following four types of relationships: clusters (in this case the data is grouped in relation to the consumer preferences or logical relationships), classes (in this the data is stored and finds its use in the location of data in the per-determined groups), sequential patterns (in this case the data is used to estimate the behavioral patterns and patterns), and associations (data is used to identify associations).

In knowledge discovery, there are different levels of data analysis and they include genetic algorithms, artificial neural networks, nearest neighbor method, data visualization, decision trees, and rule induction. The level of analysis used depends on the data that is visualized and the output needed.

Nowadays, data extraction programs are readily available in different sizes from PC platforms, mainframe, and client/server. In the enterprise-wide uses, size ranges from the 10 GB to more than 11 TB. It is important to note that two crucial technological drivers are needed and are query complexity and, database size. When more data is needed to be processed and maintained, then a more powerful system is needed that can handle complex and greater queries.

With the emergence of professional data mining companies, the costs associated with process such as web data extraction, web scraping, web crawling and web data mining have greatly being made affordable.

Source:http://ezinearticles.com/?Data-Mining-As-a-Process&id=7181033